Skip to main content

The Tariff. And Goods & Services

There's a lot of talk about the tariff lately. Especially since the US administration has changed.

The general belief is that a nation's industry, which creates goods, must be protected if the nation is to survive.

Though this idea is widely held by the greatest of minds, it is a false idea. Or, it is an idea which has not been thought through carefully.

In a more advanced nation, the goal would be to reach for the sale of more services than sales of goods. So the more advanced your nation, the more services you sell compared to goods, if you want to prosper in the most effective way. 

It’s worth noting that services are valuable only insofar as they supported or enhance the creation of real wealth, not when they existed to extract it without contributing, such as when monopolies use services to extract economic rent.

Services are more effective at producing wealth having fewer more costly inputs of goods, than the production of goods directly, which cost more to deliver than the services per dollar input. Especially in the way that better services assist in boosting the division of labour and a nations comparative advantage. Trade policy should reflect a nation’s strengths, whether in goods or services, rather than blindly protecting domestic goods production at all costs.

"Goods will not be imported into any country unless they can be obtained more easily by producing something else and exchanging it for them, than by producing them directly." George in Protection or Free Trade.

While this applies to tangible goods, George’s broader point is about comparative advantage—a concept he grasped intuitively, even if he didn’t use the modern term. He recognized that "something else" could include services. If a country is better at providing services (e.g., shipping, finance, or skilled labor) than manufacturing certain goods, it’s foolish to protect the latter at the expense of the former. He saw protectionism as a rigid policy that ignores this dynamic, locking nations into less efficient production patterns.

George’s argument shines through when he discusses trade’s role in the division of labor. He noted that some regions are better suited to services due to "differences in industrial development, in habits, customs, and related occupations" (Chapter 12). For example, a nation with a skilled workforce or strategic location might excel at shipping, banking, or education—services that generate wealth more effectively than forcing domestic production of goods it can import cheaply. He saw protectionism as a backward step, propping up industries that might no longer align with a country’s evolving capabilities.

In his view, if services are what you’re now better at producing, protecting goods production is not just inefficient—it’s economically irrational. It’s like forcing a skilled artisan to farm when he could trade his craft for food more profitably. George’s insight here predates modern economic shifts toward service-dominated economies, showing his forward-thinking grasp of trade dynamics.

George didn’t just judge services by their productivity in a vacuum—he actively contrasted them with goods in the context of trade policy, arguing that protectionism fails when it ignores a nation’s best path to prosperity. He went deeper by showing that economic evolution demands flexibility, and services could be that next step for some societies. His point wasn’t that services inherently outshine goods, but that protecting goods production at the expense of a service advantage is a misstep—a deeper critique than I first conveyed.

He pointed out that protecting goods production is foolish if services are where your strength lies, framing it as a practical application of free trade principles. His insight was less about elevating services philosophically and more about exposing the rigidity of protectionism in a changing economic landscape. 

We should take care not to elevate services above goods as a mode of production. The point is to say that once a nation reaches a certain break point, services will become that much more important to devote scarce capital to. And to attempt to protect the production of goods in the face of cheaper foreign competition can only harm the home nation in the end, unless the home nation can truly produce those goods at a cheaper price all else being equal. And if it can then why all the fuss already?

So services, being indirectly involved in the production of wealth, have more power to produce wealth. And for that reason should be targeted by the home nation as soon as it has the ability to do so. And especially when the costs of continuing to produce goods, rather than services, is starting to negatively impact the home economy. 

There may be reasons to protect the home industry, such as for security, in case of acts of God. But in a globalised world, there will always be someone willing to sell you those goods you're now short of, who is not harmed by God yet. OK OK. So keep a stock of industry in goods to protect against 1000 year black swans but that can be a relatively small stock. The home industry does not need protecting.

Is there a justification for the protection of home services though?

Perhaps. When a foreign nation is trying to buy up the home industry at a temporary loss. In the hope that eventually the foreigner will be able to raise prices high and the home industry cannot afford to restart it. But this is really 'super-protectionism' by the foreigner. Where the stupidity of borders has expanded. The people of a foreign nation are humans too. Nature knows nothing about borders. So, in the final analysis here, nature will take care of it all with no accounting for justice, equality, fairness or love. She will deliver truth. In the end the entire economy of the world will suffer through super protection, even the foreign industry if it initially succeeds will pay for it in the end.

So I believe Mr Trump is right here to counter-tariff a foreigner trying to corner their market. He can see super-protectionism is a fools policy and is trying to save the world.

Note: a large part of this - on the comparative advantage of services, after arguing about it gleaned from Grok.





Popular Posts

The 450 Volt Truth: From Orwell to Obedience

A thread on dystopia, Milgram and breaking the agentic state: why people act irrationally, and often violently, when a tribal social structure and its hierarchy are brought under serious scrutiny. This is a tricky topic. Please read the Obedience Glossary of Terms before proceeding. Why this matters This piece grew out of a long conversation with Grok. I had to interrogate the AI quite a bit, and I was astonished at the intelligence it produced. What follows is the most pertinent part of that exchange, tightened up. Do not be fooled into thinking this is just another Orwell analysis. Orwell only sets the scene for what comes later: the agentic state, and how power uses it to control the masses. It may not have all the answers. It might be wrong. A lot of it is very hard to believe is happening. But it still seems to fit the bizarre world of system-wide dissonance we all live in, and take part in, better than any of the alternatives. So it deserves your continued attention. By al...

A Dialogue on the UK's Accession to the United States (UKEXIT)

I want the government to start a conversation: could the countries of the United Kingdom leave the UK and join the United States as individual states? Let us call the idea UKEXIT—pronounced “yukezit”. This petition asks us to examine what that could mean for people's lives: their rights, prosperity, identity and future. It is a proposal for dialogue, not immediate change. If Wales , Northern Ireland , Scotland or England left the UK, it would end their system of constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy . As separate US states, they would govern themselves within the federal system and receive its protection. Immediate change is unlikely. But the disconnect in UK leadership calls for a serious conversation. The government should honestly help the public compare ways of governing and think harder about nationalism, patriotism and multiculturalism—and what each leaves to our descendants. Why consider it? What could improve? What happens if we do nothing? Concl...

Government & Tax Death Toll

I'm going to show you how government and taxation causes more excess death than any other factor, even global wars and pandemics. It is and always has been the biggest genocide of all. And it’s deliberate. Government doesn’t just fail to save lives — it takes them, at scale.  2–6 million globally 200K–400K in the U.S. 50K–80K in the UK Every year. Every tax. Every regulation. Cumulatively since 1970 government and tax killed between 160 and 300 million people across the globe  More than all 20th century wars and genocides combined (260M) In the U.S. ten times more than all U.S. combat deaths in history (10 * 1.2M) In the UK equivalent to 1 in 15 of all deaths And the nations with more regulations and a higher tax to GDP ratio such as the UK and US, tend to kill more of their own citizens per capita. The poorest nations have a better record than the richest. All this excess death is rooted in the institutions of taxation - the theft of private property, by force, against your f...

The Orwell Test

I'm going to show you how to test if you're either: an autonomous individual, or an obedient instrument of authority We all believe we make our choices with free will. And that thought is just telling us how things are.  Yet in making 'free' choices are we actually signalling obedience to the political tribe we have chosen to rule us and are unconscious of it?  Do not get drawn back into the unconscious and think: "well I'm somewhere in between, I do a little bit of obedience here and a little bit of autonomy there." It is not a relative activity. It is a binary one at the root. One has either submitted one's autonomy to a Master, or one has not.  At the root of one's psyche. And once the root has been overwhelmed all else is lost that follows. But if one can fight to defend the root divine spark, everything is resolved. Sure, you might be attacked by a psychopath one day and this didn't help did it. But we're talking about the rediscoverin...

Facing Draco, Mining Dorado - The Coming Great Recession

This is a proposal to show how the 18.6 year real estate cycle is a hang over from times where the mechanics of the lunar month were used by high priests of the time to forecast ancient agricultural cycles - what we would today call a business cycle always culminating in a financial crisis and great recession. This is not a prediction or a prophet speaking. It is saying it will happen - a forecast. I've been saying 2026 for 15 years now. I might be wrong about the exact date. Give or take a year. The 18.6 year astronomical period is governed by the intersection of lunar and solar eclipses. It is known scientifically as the Saros Cycle. Where all 3 harmonics of the orbit of the moon coincide once every 18.6 years. The ancient scholars knew this and had been measuring it for aeons. And the politicians of the time used it to name the day when the economy had to be deliberately reset by fiat. This reset was necessary because they noticed around 19 years is as long as an economy can sur...

Mortgages, For the Greater Good

I'm going to tell you about how mortgages have evolved into a neodemocratic political tool,  that mortgages harmonise all political parties meaning it doesn't matter who you vote for any more,  why the homeowner never funds bank bailouts and the saver or tenant always does. And of course, the effects of this on 2026 and how to prepare your household for the next great recession. Source: UK Ministry of Justice At a property network event a property manager told me recently how they'd made it with multiple properties through the past two business cycles in 89 and 08. But didn't know or had forgotten how. And how their old boss who took more risk and had way to many bonds on his books, had not made it, because he was trying to be super wealthy - 'the bad manager'. I suggested the property manager had survived well because he'd not got greedy. He had not got over-leveraged on mortgage debt. And that government of all party's will implicitly protect the mortg...

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this blog about?  This blog tells you all about my cosmic exile ,  my propensity to obey authority above all other social actions and how I tend to project my darker side onto the world to escape from all this - to prevent it from coming into the light. The blog will tell me how this is manifest in the material world in my daily activity, in the form of forbidden knowledge. This knowledge is available all the time and is all around me yet I'm not permitted to speak it about without risking further  exile from the tribe.  Because in the end, we are all suffering from being born in to the same condition - a condition of cosmic exile. Each post will attempt to present the good news - that by doing the inner work I can redeem myself from all this, immediately, if I choose it, and so can we all. Instead of fueling more chaos and incoherence in the world.  I can't be more specific on the subject matter. Because it covers everything which happens on the ...

Recovery of Lost and Stolen Bitcoin Is Easier Than Ever

What if my stolen assets are mixed and dispersed into a thousand wallets. How can you possibly get that back for me? For a quick analysis see the FAQ here tohonesty.com I sometimes get asked this question by smart people genuinely interested in how the method works. It's about trying to understand how we can still recover your assets easily, even after a thief spreads your stolen assets out so widely, it feels like it's now impossible to recover.  The answer is the same in all cases. Because crypto in the eyes of the law is identical in every way to all other forms of property, the recovery method will use the same existing well known techniques. One does not have to go into the precise mechanics of it, legal experts and analysts already know.  The question is really about 'money laundering' and how to overwhelm the attempt by bad actors to hide the stolen assets from the law. Money laundering has been a scam method since the dawn of time. So any remediation will be th...

Introducing Obedience Theory

Let me put forward an idea that might be new to you. We'll call it 'obedience theory'. At its core, the theory explains how obedience serves as the main way people climb socially and economically. You can dig into the articles on this site for a proper deep dive. In any society built on hierarchy - and they all are - obedience underpins every decision we make. Other factors play a role in our social drives, but they're far less important. They're just theatrical offshoots of obedience. Choosing Your Tribe As a citizen, I will pick obedience to the authority that spins the tale I most want to hear. That's my tribe. I give it my obedience as the key thing to advance socially and economically. Of course, I do other stuff to get ahead. But obedience tops the list by miles.  Public displays of obedience to my tribe - what I call 'signalling' - trump everything else in social and economic terms. This even beats out abstract principle values like objective fact...

Global National Socialism & Saving Human Consciousness

I'm going to tell you about Global National Socialism (GNS)  GNS is a worldview and political movement which sees a single party and a single nation as the optimal condition for social organisation. Some refer to it as globalism though that is too weak a description. Think about the national socialists of 1930's Germany and you will have a better idea about what it means, though it won't look much like that on the surface, more like the Soviet Union and probably something like neither. Some might call it 'omni-socialism'. It's a state of the world where there's a single nation, run by a single party, with a single all encompassing worldview of obedience . Whatever is becomes it will be systemically authoritarian with centralised control of everything. It's not dumb to call it nationalism, in spite of being a global authority. It is one nation where everything is driven by a cult of national superiority. A nation of ideal people, only. Not ideal in race, ...