Volumes of space will soon command a rent. The most valuable locations will attract the greatest demand and the highest rents. Heard it before? Yes. Right here on the earth beneath your feet.
The problem Mr. Musk is taking into space
Mr. Musk has had spectacular success in increasing productive power. I welcome it. But here is the problem I do not think he has yet detected: if every economy is built on privatising the commons, the same problem will follow him into space—at a greater scale.
Labour-saving devices let us produce more with the same effort. But that makes the best locations more valuable. More people want access to them, and the gains capitalise into higher rents and higher selling prices for those locations.
On earth, we call it land and location value. In space, extend the same reasoning to orbits, spectrum and planetary sites. These are the commons, not things we made by our own labour. If exclusive rights to them are privatised, their owners can collect the rent generated by everyone else's productive success.
The rockets can carry us beyond the earth. They cannot carry us beyond this economic structure. Leave it unchanged, and spectacularly greater productive power will feed spectacularly greater rents.
Location, location, location
We call it land area here and space volume there. Space value instead of land value. Three dimensions instead of two. Economically, both are still “land”. The income from owning either will still be called economic rent—or, more commonly, just rent.
Unintelligent people will say, “But space is unlimited. The rent will tend towards zero.” Avoid these people. They will bring harm to your household and descendants. Seriously. Avoid them like the plague.
Rent does not come from sheer size. Land can have a negative value if nobody wants it, and there is a hell of a lot of poor land.
Where everyone really wants to be in space will be ultra-limited. It will be right next to where everyone else wants to be, because the community already there has made that location valuable. Think of a city. The same economic reasons apply.
There is no better way—indeed, no other useful way—to measure how well an economy is doing than to see whether its common stock of valuable land, and now space, is growing or declining. The measure is the relative price of rent.
The first pioneer and the neighbour
The first pioneer will not notice this. There is no competition yet for the valuable space. The pioneer is the whole community. Has that pioneer therefore created all the added value?
There is no rental value yet: only one tenant, with no separate owner to pay except God.
Then a second pioneer arrives and sets up next door. The community has potentially doubled in value. There are now multiple tenants, and the first pioneer accounts for only a nominal 50% of the newly emerged rental value.
The first cannot justly claim 100% of it, or sell it outright for a capital sum. That new value was not created alone. Both helped create it by virtue of the second arriving, and both benefit. Their space has acquired an economic value.
Keep what you make—not what everyone makes
Be careful here. The improvements—the capital made by the first pioneer—still belong to that pioneer by right. Not the space rents created equally by both.
Those rents are real, but not material things. They appear later in the exchange of things. Space, just like land on earth, is not capital. Unless you still believe in slavery, which many will still try to convince you is a good thing.
Unintelligent people will call space value capital, much as they once described chattel slaves—today referred to as corporate employees. Unconsciously, we see them as slaves to be exchanged like food or fuel. Left- and right-wing planet savers are equally and eternally caught in this pathology, despite the euphemistic spin.
Where will the next business go?
Most space today has little value, like land in the Sahara, which may even have negative value.
But the first business to get there and use it productively will be in an excellent monopoly position. The next business wanting to make a living in space will be in direct competition with that pioneer.
Where is the guaranteed location this second pioneer will choose to build its product?
I'll leave that to you. If you are open-minded, the answer will be easy. If you are possessed by any ideology at all, you will never know, because you will not be able to understand.
Find out more here: Space Land